Old Surety Life Insurance Medicare Supplement Plans

Old Surety Life Insurance Company is an Oklahoma City-based carrier that has specialized in Medicare Supplement (Medigap) insurance since 1932. Unlike many carriers on this list, Old Surety focuses exclusively on Medigap coverage — it does not offer Medicare Advantage or Part D prescription drug plans.

Old Surety Medigap Plan Options

Old Surety currently offers Medigap Plans A, C, F, and G, which help cover the deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance that Original Medicare leaves behind. Plan availability varies by state, so it's worth confirming which options Old Surety offers where you live before comparing rates.

Where Old Surety Life Insurance Is Available

Old Surety writes Medicare Supplement plans in select states, including Kansas, Missouri, Texas, Colorado, Oklahoma, and North Carolina. Coverage and pricing can differ significantly from state to state, so an Old Surety Medigap plan quote in one state may look very different from a neighboring state.

Old Surety Life Insurance Reviews: What to Know

Old Surety has a long track record in the senior insurance market and a reputation for personal, responsive customer service. As a smaller regional carrier, though, its rates and plan availability can vary more by state than larger national names, and its financial strength ratings may not match bigger insurers. That doesn't mean Old Surety is a bad option — it often means comparing it side-by-side with other carriers pays off.

Is Old Surety Life Insurance Right for You?

The best way to know whether Old Surety is competitive in your area is to compare its Medigap rates against other carriers we work with. Since Medigap benefits are standardized by plan letter, the carrier you choose mainly affects price, customer service, and long-term rate stability — not the coverage itself.

Want to see how Old Surety's rates compare? Contact us at 800-577-2075 for a free, no-obligation quote comparison across the carriers available in your state.